[FONT="]It is worth keeping in mind that – with the exception of the tentacled apparitions –we are in fact living in Lovecraft’s universe. It is not “the love that moves the sun and the other stars” as in Dante’s theocentric vision of the cosmos. Rather, it is indeed the case that the planets “roll in their horror unheeded, without knowledge, or purpose, or name”. The world is a cold machine that grinds us up – seldom with any malice, because malice would entail recognizing that we even exist.
But our readiness (depending on your personal convictions as to the nature of the universe) to accept statements such as “The world is a cold machine that grinds us up” hints at a fundamental flaw in cosmic indifferentism – our congenital inability to conceive of anything – once we accept that there is a “something” – as being truly mindless and indifferent. Statements like the Zappfian “Nature has given us cognitive powers that lead to outsized suffering” may seem like attempts at affirming the uncaring nature of the universe. But they can also be interpreted as inadvertent conjurings of bad guys to be held responsible. If we get down to brass tacks there are no such things as “nature” or “the world”. These are reifications born of a human mind that cannot help but to conceptualize complex bunches of stuff in terms of discrete entities complete with goals and intentions analogous to those of human beings. Saying that nature does not care is like saying the color green doesn’t like what’s on TV right now – it falsely implies that there is an individuated entity called “nature” that has the ability to care or not care about something.
Being made as we are made (to borrow Ligotti’s words), we have no choice but to view the facts of existence in our image, conjuring up monstrous entities like “the world”. But we are not really made as we are made. Rather, we are become as we are become. There is no vast, malicious entity called “nature”, no Will-to-live, no Azathoth, no Nethescurial, no blind watchmaker to whom we can turn to have our grievances redressed. There is only a bunch of stuff that happened. And here we are.[/FONT]